Ultra-Creamy Fresh Homemade Ricotta {+ Video!}

In this post, I’ll teach you how to make ultra-creamy, 4-ingredient homemade ricotta in under 1 hour (including straining time). Follow my step-by-step recipe instructions and video. So fresh and creamy!

Ahh… Ricotta (rhee-koh-tah). Saying it out loud makes everything sound better, right? Whether it’s tossed with fresh homemade pasta and pomodoro sauce, folded into my one-bowl Italian almond cake or tucked into homemade ravioli, creamy ricotta will make anyone weak in the knees!

Now, I’m assuming you’re here because you want to make it yourself. You’re curious. Compared to store-bought, my homemade ricotta recipe is a completely different beast. It’s more creamy. Less grainy. Not as wet. The taste is light and delicate, and the whimsical fluffy texture is an unexpected conversation starter.

If this is your first time making ricotta, don’t worry about what you’re gonna do with it: think simple. Drizzle with olive oil, black pepper and serve warm with sourdough crostini as pictured above. Or, dollop on top of pasta for a marbled “cream sauce” effect. Get to know it. Understand it. Indulge in one of the most to-die-for recipes you’ll ever make at home.

What You’ll Learn.

In this post, I’ll teach you how to make fresh homemade ricotta with 4 simple ingredients: milk, cream, lemon juice and salt. You do not need any fancy, expensive equipment to make fresh homemade ricotta. However, cheesecloth and a fine mesh strainer are required. The entire process takes less than 1 hour to complete, including straining time. You’ll end up with 1 heaping cup (265 g). You can also make it ahead.

But Please, Don’t Call It Cheese.

Did you know ricotta is technically not cheese? While flipping through American Sfoglino from which this recipe is loosely based, I learned ricotta does not undergo traditional fermentation. Therefore, it doesn’t count as cheese. Ricotta is actually the by-product of cheese production, which is what you’ll re-create in this post. Sounds super lengthy and technical, but it’s actually really easy to do. And fun.

Ricotta Origins: The Backstory

Ricotta was born out of necessity in Italy’s cucina povera (poor kitchen), by way of Sicily, birthing one of the most celebrated products in the world. Generally speaking: when cheese is made you get leftover whey, a cloudy, yellow-ish liquid. To avoid waste, because no one did that back in the day, clever cheese makers re-purposed the whey into something entirely new.

Making Ricotta.

Ricotta means “re-cooked” or cooked twice. First, milk is used to make cheese like Pecorino. Then, the leftover whey is heated again until curds float to the surface. When you strain these curds, you get fresh ricotta. This is the traditional method. For modern recipes (since most people do not have leftover whey to start with), lemon juice is added to the heated milk mixture to create ricotta curds instead.

Why This Recipe Works:

• I use a combination of whole milk and cream to emulate the richness of sheep’s milk, the traditional milk used to make ricotta in Sicily. My ratio is 3:1 (milk to cream).
• Allowing the mixture to rest for 10 minutes before straining ensures light, delicate and fluffy ricotta.
• This is a small batch recipe, which yields about 1 heaping cup (265 g). Ricotta doesn’t last long in the fridge, about 4 days, so only make what you need. This recipe can easily be doubled.

Homemade Ricotta Ingredients & Supplies (You Will Need):

Ingredients:

• Whole Milk (not ultra pasteurized!): I recommend whole cow’s milk for creamy flavor and texture. Alternatively, 2% or 1% milk can be used; but the final result will not be as creamy. Ultra pasteurized milk does not work for homemade ricotta. It won’t curdle properly. Look for good-quality pasteurized milk, either regular or organic. This recipe was successfully tested with Whole Foods 365 Organic Milk, Horizon Organic Milk and Trader Joe’s Organic Milk.
• Cream: Heavy cream or whipping cream can be used. Both work. Oddly enough, ultra-pasteurized cream can be used, which is a good thing because regular pasteurized cream is hard to find.
• Lemon Juice: This is your acidic ingredient needed to curdle the milk and cream mixture. It does not impart a tangy taste unless you add more than what’s indicated in the recipe. Substitute with white vinegar or red wine vinegar.
• Salt: I prefer just a pinch, about 1/4 teaspoon of fine sea salt to enhance the creamy, dairy flavor.

Supplies:

• 7-inch Fine mesh strainer
• Cheesecloth
• Heavy bottom pot or enameled cast iron braiser (as pictured below).

How To Make Fresh Homemade Ricotta: Step-By-Step Recipe

• In a heavy bottom pot, add the milk, cream and salt. Adjust the heat to medium-high.
• Bring the mixture to a rolling boil, approximately 200-206 F/ 93-97 C. Do not boil aggressively; the ricotta will be rubbery. Tip: while the mixture is heating up, use a wooden spoon to stir in a “figure 8” motion so nothing sticks to the bottom of the pot. Scorched milk = bitter ricotta. Once the mixture has come to a boil, the next steps below happen quickly and in succession. Do not lolly-gag around!
• In this order: add the lemon juice, stir twice, and turn off the heat. Do not stir; the mixture will start to curdle. Let it sit (untouched) on the warm turned off burner for 10 minutes. Small and large curds will float to the surface.

• With a slotted spoon, transfer the ricotta curds to a cheesecloth-lined strainer.
• Drain over a deep bowl at room temperature, about 10-15 minutes for light and fluffy ricotta. For drier ricotta, strain longer. The desired consistency is ultimately up to you.
• When finished, the ricotta will still be warm. Use right away, or transfer to an air-tight container and refrigerate until ready to use.

Homemade Ricotta Tips:

• Understand texture. When the ricotta is strained at room temperature, it will be light, fluffy and warm. When chilled in the refrigerator, it becomes more creamy, slightly dense and cold. Both textures and temperatures can be used for a wide variety of ricotta recipes and dishes.
• Use a thermometer (optional). Most ricotta recipes recommend heating the milk and cream to a specific temperature. Use a digital thermometer to double check. If you don’t have one, just look for visual clues: the mixture should come to a rolling boil, with frothy bubbles around the sides and in the center of the pot.
• Save your cheesecloth. Wash used cheesecloth in mild, soapy water and rinse clean. Drape over the back of a chair to air-dry.
• Don’t use ultra pasteurized milk! I mentioned this earlier, but I’m going to say it again just in case you missed it! Ultra pasteurized milk doesn’t not curdle properly for ricotta. Use regular pasteurized milk instead.

How To Store Fresh Homemade Ricotta

Portion homemade ricotta into an air-right container and store in the fridge, up to 4 days. I like glass containers. Pour off any residual liquid on the surface, if necessary, before using.

Can You Freeze Homemade Ricotta?

No. Because ricotta is made with mostly milk, when frozen, ice crystals will form changing the structure and texture of the ricotta. That’s why this is a small batch recipe; it’s doubtful you’ll have any leftover depending on what you’re using it for. No waste!

Can You Make Ricotta Ahead Of Time?

Yes. Ricotta can be made up to 4 days in advance. Compared to freshly made ricotta, the texture will be more firm due to extra chilling time in the refrigerator. Use the ricotta cold or bring to room temperature first.

What To Do With Leftover Whey?

After straining the ricotta, you’ll get leftover whey at the bottom of the bowl. You can either toss it, or make something else. Taste it first. It’s a little tangy and salty, so I recommend adding whey to recipes where this flavor profile makes sense: sourdough bread, sourdough focaccia and/or sourdough pizza crust. Additionally, it can be used in smoothies and to ferment vegetables if that’s your thing! Whey will last for a few months in the fridge or freezer; however I like to freeze mine right away (I’ll forget about it otherwise).

More Ricotta Recipes To Try!

• Soft Italian Ricotta Cookies
• One-Bowl Italian Almond Ricotta Cake
• Beginner’s Guide To Fresh Homemade Ravioli

Print